Comment Reply Email vs WP Mail Logging — WordPress

Comment Reply vs WP Mail Logging

Side-by-side comparison · 24 data points

Comment Reply

4.8·33reviews·3,000+installs

wordpress

Change

1. Listing metadata

Field-level data

	Comment Reply	WP Mail Logging
Tagline	—	—
Description	3125 / 5000 chars63% used	2630 / 5000 chars53% used
Screenshots	—	—
Languages
Platforms	WordPress	WordPress
Developer	Arno Welzel	Syed Balkhi
Listed	—	—
Last updated	—	—

2. Categories & rankings

Shared categories on the same row · in-category position inline

Comment Reply

WP Mail Logging

Shared

At a glance

4 metrics · auto-computed

Feature comparison between Comment Reply Email Notification and WP Mail Logging
Metric	Comment Reply Email Notification	WP Mail Logging
Rating	★ 4.8 ★	4.7 ★
Total reviews	33	★ 365
Active installs	3,000+	300,000+
Free plan	—	—

Keyword	Comment Reply	WP Mail Logging
custom form	#653	Not ranked
form	#745	Not ranked
forms	#807	Not ranked

5. App details

Long-form description · keyword frequency

Comment Reply

This plugin allows visitors to subscribe to get answers to their comments via e-mail. Warning This plugin uses the “wp_insert_comment” hook, therefore, everytime a comment is created, a notification is likely to be sent. If you are importing comments into your blog, it’s a good idea to disable this plugin. Sending e-mails does not work? The plugin uses the standard WordPress e-mail function. If you have problems getting e-mails sent, you might try using plugins like https://wordpress.org/plugins/wp-mail-smtp/ to improve sending e-mails from your site. Customizing the layout of the checkboxes The label next to the checkboxes don’t contain a whitespace. Depending on your theme you might want to add a custom style like this to get a space between the checkbox and the label: input#cren_subscribe_to_comment, input#cren_gdpr { margin-right: 0.5em; } The plugin does not add this style be default as it depends on your theme if this is neccessary. Customizing the email template To customize the email template, copy the “templates” folder to your theme folder (a child theme should be used to avoid losing the custom templates when the theme is updated). The plugin will look for templates on the “/wp-content/themes/[THEME]/templates/cren/” folder; if a custom template is not found, then it will fallback to the default template. Templates folder on GitHub: https://github.com/arnowelzel/worpdress-comment-reply-email-notification/tree/master/templates Changing the subscription checkbox label The checkbox label can be changed with the cren_comment_checkbox_label filter. This way you can update the text to your taste and keep the plugin updated. Changing the GDPR checkbox label The GDPR checkbox label can be changed with the cren_gdpr_checkbox_label filter. This way you can update the text to your taste and keep the plugin updated. Modifiying HTML output Using the filters cren_gdpr_checkbox_html and cren_comment_subscribe_html you can modify the HTML output of the checkboxes if needed. Example: add_filter('cren_gdpr_checkbox_html', function(string $html_output, string $label_text, string $privacy_policy_url): string { $html_output = ' ' . $label_text . ' * ( Privacy Policy ) '; return $html_output; }, 10, 3); add_filter('cren_comment_subscribe_html', function(string $html_output, string $label_text, bool $checked_default): string { $checked = $checked_default ? 'checked' : ''; $html_output = ' ' . $label_text . ' '; return $html_output; }, 10, 3);

Top keywords

label12×3.01%
html10×2.51%
checkbox9×2.26%
html output8×2.01%
output8×2.01%
cren7×1.75%
string7×1.75%
checkbox label6×1.50%
comment6×1.50%
gdpr6×1.50%
templates6×1.50%
text6×1.50%

WP Mail Logging

WP Mail Logging is the most popular plugin for logging emails sent from your WordPress site. Simply activate it and it will work immediately, no extra configuration is needed. Are your WordPress emails not being sent or delivered? Use this plugin to log all outgoing emails from your WordPress site. If there are any errors when sending the email from your site, our email logs will catch that error and display it to you. This will allow you to debug and fix your email sending issue. Did a client not receive your email? Our email logs allow you to resend any email that was sent from your site. No more lost emails! Do you just want to keep a record of all emails sent from your site? By default, WordPress and your web host do not log, store or keep track of emails sent from your website. This plugin will allow you to do just that. Our email logs will store every email that is sent from your WordPress site. You can search and view a particular email log, inspect its content or attachments, and even resend that email. What email information is logged? All emails sent from your WordPress site are logged. And here is the information that is stored: Email Subject Email Content (HTML or text) Email Attachments Email Headers (to, from, reply-to, cc, bcc, …) Error Message (in case there was an error while attempting to send the email) IP Address of originating server (can be enabled in the settings) Date and Time of the email Receiver (the TO email address) Why are my logged emails still not delivered to the inbox? There are a lot of steps that emails have to make in order to be delivered to the recipient’s inbox. When your WordPress site sends an email, there’s no guarantee it will be delivered. This is what the email’s journey looks like: WordPress creates an email WordPress passes the email to your website host and that email gets logged by our plugin The host server takes the email and sends it (SMTP or Mail Transfer Agent) Recipient server receives or blocks the email If the email is accepted, the spam filter decides if it goes to the inbox or the spam folder Recipients see the email and might open it. This plugin does not track delivery after step 2. If you have deliverability issues, we suggest installing the WP Mail SMTP plugin. WP Mail SMTP fixes WordPress email deliverability problems, you can choose between 12 email providers (Gmail, Outlook, SendLayer, Mailgun, …) to resolve your email sending issue and it’s super easy to set up. WP Mail SMTP is trusted by more than 3 million websites. Credits The plugin was created and launched in 2014 by Christian Zöller.

Top keywords

email30×6.44%
wordpress10×2.15%

Frequently asked

Common questions about this comparison

Which has better reviews, Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Comment Reply Email Notification (4.8★, 33 reviews) and WP Mail Logging (4.7★, 365 reviews) are essentially tied on rating. Look at review velocity and individual reviewer quotes — both visible on each app's detail page — to differentiate.

Should I choose Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Comment Reply Email Notification holds the higher average rating (4.8★ vs 4.7★). That is the one dimension AppRanks can separate them on here — read both apps' detail pages for the feature breakdown and recent listing changes.

Which is faster to set up, Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Both apps are one-click installs from the WordPress Plugin Directory. WP Mail Logging has the deeper published review base (365 vs 33), which often — though not always — accompanies better-tested setup docs. AppRanks doesn't measure setup time directly: read the recent reviews on each app's detail page for user-reported install experience.

Which works better for small vs large WordPress Plugin Directory site owners?

Comment Reply Email Notification typically suits early-stage and growth-mode teams based on its published review base (33 reviews). WP Mail Logging typically suits early-stage and growth-mode teams based on its published review base (365 reviews). A larger review base generally means the app has been exercised at scale — relevant if you are processing high volume or handling enterprise compliance requirements.

Can I migrate data between Comment Reply Email Notification and WP Mail Logging?

Migration support varies by app and category. Comment Reply Email Notification and WP Mail Logging both publish their export options on their marketplace listing pages (or in their support docs); some apps offer one-click import from competitors, others require CSV. The fastest check: search "import from Comment Reply Email Notification" in each app's help center. AppRanks does not track migration tooling directly — this is a category-specific capability worth verifying before commitment.

Comment Reply vs WP Mail Logging

Comment Reply

1. Listing metadata

2. Categories & rankings

WP Mail Logging

At a glance

AppRanks verdict

3. Search rankings

4. Activity in the last 90 days

Comment Reply · 1 changes

WP Mail Logging · 0 changes

5. App details

Frequently asked

Which has better reviews, Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Should I choose Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Which is faster to set up, Comment Reply Email Notification or WP Mail Logging?

Which works better for small vs large WordPress Plugin Directory site owners?

Can I migrate data between Comment Reply Email Notification and WP Mail Logging?

See full keyword rankings, install trends, and weekly alerts

More popular comparisons