Side-by-side comparison · 24 data points
Reduce risk before fulfillment. Protect margins with shipping insurance and checkout protection.
| InsureShield & CommerceShield | Umbrella | |
|---|---|---|
| Tagline | ||
| Description | ||
| Screenshots | images | images |
| Languages | ||
| Platforms | ||
| Developer | ||
| Listed |
| Metric | InsureShield & CommerceShield | Umbrella: In‑house Warranties |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 3.8 ★ | ★ 5.0 ★ |
| Total reviews | ★ 46 | 11 |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Pricing | Free to install | Free plan available |
| Built for Shopify | — | — |
| Pricing tiers | 3 tiers | 3 tiers |
| Listed features | 5 | 5 |
| Languages | 1 supported | 17 supported |
| Listed since | Jan 2021 | Jun 2025 |
Based on the data on this page, Umbrella: In‑house Warranties is the stronger choice for most Shopify App Store merchants — 5.0★ vs InsureShield & CommerceShield's 3.8★ is a meaningful gap that usually reflects real product or support quality differences across the user base.
Pricing entry tiers: InsureShield & CommerceShield at Free to install, Umbrella: In‑house Warranties at Free plan available. Check each app's tier structure for the capacity limits you actually need before deciding — the headline number is the same shape, but the gating shape per tier (seats, usage volume, integrations) varies.
Recommended by size: small/early-stage merchants who need fast install and low risk should default to Umbrella: In‑house Warranties; mid-market and enterprise merchants with specific feature requirements should evaluate both — InsureShield & CommerceShield's 46-review base may include the workflow context that matches your specific use case better than Umbrella: In‑house Warranties's broader-but-shallower coverage.
This verdict is generated from the live marketplace data on this page — rating, review count, pricing tier, and category position all refresh from the canonical Shopify App Store listing every 24 hours. AppRanks does not accept payment to influence comparison outcomes; the methodology is documented on the About page and applies identically to every pair on the site.
Read each app's audit: InsureShield & CommerceShield audit • Umbrella: In‑house Warranties audit
| Last updated | — | — |
|---|
| Keyword | InsureShield & CommerceShield | Umbrella |
|---|---|---|
| insurance | #13 | #18 |
| stolen packages | #22 | #16 |
| warranties and insurance | #22 | #17 |
| damaged | #24 | #24 |
No tracked changes.
Both InsureShield & CommerceShield and Umbrella: In‑house Warranties offer paid plans only. InsureShield & CommerceShield starts at Free to install; Umbrella: In‑house Warranties starts at Free plan available. Compare the per-tier features in the Pricing section above before committing.
Umbrella: In‑house Warranties has the higher average rating (5.0★ from 11 reviews) compared to InsureShield & CommerceShield (3.8★ from 46 reviews). Both are tracked daily by AppRanks, so the figures here update each refresh cycle.
Umbrella: In‑house Warranties holds the higher average rating (5.0★ vs 3.8★). That is the one dimension AppRanks can separate them on here — read both apps' detail pages for the feature breakdown and recent listing changes.
Both apps are one-click installs from the Shopify App Store. InsureShield & CommerceShield has the deeper published review base (46 vs 11), which often — though not always — accompanies better-tested setup docs. AppRanks doesn't measure setup time directly: read the recent reviews on each app's detail page for user-reported install experience.
InsureShield & CommerceShield typically suits early-stage and growth-mode teams based on its published review base (46 reviews). Umbrella: In‑house Warranties typically suits early-stage and growth-mode teams based on its published review base (11 reviews). A larger review base generally means the app has been exercised at scale — relevant if you are processing high volume or handling enterprise compliance requirements.
Migration support varies by app and category. InsureShield & CommerceShield and Umbrella: In‑house Warranties both publish their export options on their marketplace listing pages (or in their support docs); some apps offer one-click import from competitors, others require CSV. The fastest check: search "import from Umbrella: In‑house Warranties" in each app's help center. AppRanks does not track migration tooling directly — this is a category-specific capability worth verifying before commitment.
