Appstle Loyalty Program Reward vs Wishlist by Square

Side-by-side comparison

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward

5.0·1.5kreviews

Comprehensive loyalty program with rewards, referrals, store credits, cart redemption, VIP, and more

Built for ShopifyshopifyFree plan available

Change

New comparison

Wishlist by Square

5.0·152reviews

Boost sales with Wishlist features - let shoppers save favorites in a personal wish list

Built for ShopifyshopifyFree plan available

Change

At a glance

9 metrics · ★ = leads on this metric

Feature comparison between Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square
Metric	Appstle Loyalty Program Reward	Wishlist by Square
Rating	5.0 ★	5.0 ★
Total reviews	★ 1.5k	152
Free plan	Yes	Yes
Pricing	Free plan available	Free plan available
Built for Shopify	Yes	Yes
Pricing tiers	4 tiers	—
Listed features	5	5

AppRanks verdict

Generated from live data on this page

The call

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square each lead on different measured dimensions — pick by the one that matters most to you.

Where Appstle Loyalty Program Reward leads

More published reviews: 1,486 vs 152.
Lists Badges, Cash back and Cash back programs (+13 more) in its marketplace category features; Wishlist by Square doesn't.

Where Wishlist by Square leads

Available in more languages: 16 vs 1.
Ranks higher in Customer loyalty: #5 vs #15 of 589.
Lists Add to cart, Conversion analytics and Dashboard (+3 more) in its marketplace category features; Appstle Loyalty Program Reward doesn't.

How this is generated

Built only from the Shopify App Store listing data shown on this page. AppRanks does not accept payment to influence comparisons. Read the methodology

Read each app's audit: Appstle Loyalty Program Reward audit • Wishlist by Square audit

1. Listing metadata

Field-level data

Field	Appstle Loyalty Program Reward	Wishlist by Square
Tagline	“Comprehensive loyalty program with rewards, referrals, store credits, cart redemption, VIP, and more”	“Boost sales with Wishlist features - let shoppers save favorites in a personal wish list”
Listing audit	93/100 listing audit	90/100 listing audit
Screenshots	10 images	6 images
Languages	English	ArabicDanishGermanEnglishSpanish+11 more
Platforms	Shopify	Shopify
Developer	Appstle Loyalty

Languages	1 supported	16 supported

Listed since	Feb 2023	Jun 2025

Listed	February 2, 2023	June 24, 2025

Keyword	Appstle Loyalty Program Reward	Wishlist by Square
sales	#151	#25

8. Quality signals

Reviews · velocity · latest sentiment

Signal	Appstle Loyalty Program Reward	Wishlist by Square
Average rating	5.0 ★ (1.5k)	5.0 ★ (152)

5 latest reviews · each app

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward

Jun 23, 2026
I recently moved from Wordpress to Shopify and needed a reward program. Appstle Loyalty Reward Program was the only real choice, with a solid 5 star rating. Taylor and the team not only developed an incredible app, but their support is the best by far. Super patient as I learn shopify, and super responsive + helpful wi
Curly Life - Australia's Leading Curl Store · Australia
Jun 23, 2026
they all amazing, they helped a lot ,thank you so much
ONWIZESHOP · United States
Jun 23, 2026
Amazing support. Fantastic app.
Shepherd Boy Farms · United States
Jun 22, 2026
Best customer support. They are good, they made all changes for me
iFragrance · Romania
Jun 22, 2026
Really incredible team when it comes to assistance! Setting up the loyalty programme was seamless for my customers, I cant wait to watch my community grow and would definitely recommend for anyone looking to upscale their business with a loyalty programme
Seka Candles · United Kingdom

Wishlist by Square

Review text isn't collected for this app yet (152 reviews on the marketplace).

Frequently asked

Common questions about this comparison

Is Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square cheaper?

Both Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square offer a free plan. Appstle Loyalty Program Reward lists no paid plan with a published price; Wishlist by Square lists no paid plan with a published price. Prices are as listed on the Shopify App Store; check what each tier includes in the Pricing section above.

Which has better reviews, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward (5.0★, 1,486 reviews) and Wishlist by Square (5.0★, 152 reviews) are essentially tied on rating. Look at review velocity and individual reviewer quotes — both visible on each app's detail page — to differentiate.

Should I choose Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

AppRanks cannot separate these two on rating — both sit at 5.0★. Appstle Loyalty Program Reward does carry the larger published review base (1,486 vs 152). Read both apps' detail pages for the feature breakdown and recent listing changes.

Which is faster to set up, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Both apps are one-click installs from the Shopify App Store. AppRanks doesn't measure setup time directly; Appstle Loyalty Program Reward has more published reviews to read for user-reported install experience (1,486 vs 152).

Which works better for small vs large Shopify App Store merchants?

AppRanks cannot say which fits a larger or smaller operation — there is no store-size measurement in the Shopify App Store data. What it can show: Appstle Loyalty Program Reward has 1,486 published reviews; Wishlist by Square has 152 published reviews. Compare plan limits and pricing tiers against your own volume.

Can I migrate data between Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square?

Migration support varies by app and category. Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square both publish their export options on their marketplace listing pages (or in their support docs); some apps offer one-click import from competitors, others require CSV. The fastest check: search "import from Wishlist by Square" in each app's help center. AppRanks does not track migration tooling directly — this is a category-specific capability worth verifying before commitment.

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward vs Wishlist by Square

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward

Wishlist by Square

At a glance

AppRanks verdict

1. Listing metadata

2. Pricing & plans

3. Features

4. Categories & rankings

5. Category features

6. Search rankings

7. Activity in the last 90 days

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward · 2 changes

Wishlist by Square · 1 changes

8. Quality signals

5 latest reviews · each app

9. App details

Frequently asked

Is Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square cheaper?

Which has better reviews, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Should I choose Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Which is faster to set up, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Which works better for small vs large Shopify App Store merchants?

Can I migrate data between Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square?

Track these apps' keyword rankings and listing changes

More popular comparisons

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward vs Wishlist by Square

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward

Wishlist by Square

At a glance

AppRanks verdict

1. Listing metadata

2. Pricing & plans

3. Features

4. Categories & rankings

5. Category features

6. Search rankings

7. Activity in the last 90 days

Appstle Loyalty Program Reward · 2 changes

Wishlist by Square · 1 changes

8. Quality signals

5 latest reviews · each app

9. App details

Frequently asked

Is Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square cheaper?

Which has better reviews, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Should I choose Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Which is faster to set up, Appstle Loyalty Program Reward or Wishlist by Square?

Which works better for small vs large Shopify App Store merchants?

Can I migrate data between Appstle Loyalty Program Reward and Wishlist by Square?

10. Other comparisons people make

vs Appstle Loyalty Program Reward

vs Wishlist by Square

Track these apps' keyword rankings and listing changes

More popular comparisons