These 3 apps lead WordPress Plugin Directory's Commenting category as of September 2026 — ranked by user rating, review count, and audit score, refreshed every 24 hours from the canonical WordPress marketplace listing.
Discover the top-rated commenting apps available on WordPress Plugin Directory. Rankings based on user ratings, review count, and market performance.
This is the curated shortlist — the top-ranked commenting apps. To browse every commenting app on WordPress Plugin Directory, see the full Commenting category.
This list ranks the top 3 WordPress apps classified under Commenting by the source marketplace's own taxonomy — apps appear here only because WordPress Plugin Directory itself tags them in this category, not because of any AppRanks editorial decision. Within the category set, ranking uses a Bayesian-ish blend of average rating × natural log of review count: the formula is rating × ln(reviewCount + 1), so a high-rating-low-review app doesn't leapfrog an established listing on a single 5-star outlier. The blend favors apps that are both well-reviewed AND have an established user base.
AppRanks does not invent a proprietary score for public surfaces — the rank shown mirrors the marketplace's published category position exactly, scraped on a 12-24 hour refresh cycle from the canonical WordPress Plugin Directory listing. The category lookup happens at request time and the page is cached at the edge for 1 hour to absorb traffic spikes; the underlying ranking data refreshes daily so the list stays accurate within one day of any source change. AppRanks does not editorially promote or demote apps based on advertiser or partnership status — the same blend formula applies uniformly across every app on this platform.
Ranks #1 in the WordPress Plugin Directory commenting category as a mixed-rating listing. Currently has an early-stage review volume (0 reviews). Position holds for the trailing 30-day window.
Pick if: Pick this if you want an emerging commenting option — Sided ranks #1 on WordPress Plugin Directory and is still building review depth.
Muut – Commenting and Forums Re-Imagined
Ranks #2 in the WordPress Plugin Directory commenting category as a mixed-rating listing. An early-stage review volume (19 reviews) with a no-rating average. Position holds for the trailing 30-day window.
Same data as the ranked cards, condensed into a sortable-by-eye grid: rating × review depth × pricing tier across the top 3 commenting apps on WordPress Plugin Directory.
| # | App | Rating | Reviews | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sided | 0.0★ | 0 | — |
| 2 | Muut – Commenting and Forums Re-Imagined | 3.9★ | 19 | — |
| 3 | Optin Comment Notifications | 5.0★ | 3 | — |
Want to compare any two apps in detail (features, ratings trend, pricing plans side-by-side)? Open the head-to-head page from the "Compare to #N" link on each card above. Custom multi-app comparisons, historical rank trajectory, and CSV export are available on a paid plan.
Paid plans unlock watchlists, multi-category comparisons, CSV export, and a full historical rank trajectory across every app on this list. The list itself stays free to read.
Start Free TrialPick if: Pick this if you want an emerging commenting option — Muut – Commenting and Forums Re-Imagined ranks #2 on WordPress Plugin Directory and is still building review depth.
Ranks #3 in the WordPress Plugin Directory commenting category as a category-leading listing. Tracks at no-rating across 3 reviews — early-stage review volume. Position holds for the trailing 30-day window.
Pick if: Pick this if you prioritize merchant satisfaction over scale — Optin Comment Notifications holds a 5.0-star average across 3 reviews in the commenting category.
Methodology details: /glossary/audit-score · /about.